BUSINESS REVIEWS

Sip & Sizzle

2236 First Street, Fort Myers, FL, United States

About Sip & Sizzle

Sip & Sizzle, located in Fort Myers, offers a dining experience that's hard to match. This unique eatery invites guests to cook their meals on a sizzling 500-degree stone right at their table, providing a fun and interactive culinary adventure. From the tender Surf & Turf to the perfectly cooked halibut, the menu is diverse and impressively executed. The creativity doesn't stop at the food; their drink selection, including the Plum Gimlet and Duck L’Orange Old Fashioned, is both innovative and delightful, complemented by a sommelier-curated wine list. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between relaxed and upscale, ensuring a memorable visit. With exceptional service that makes every guest feel special, Sip & Sizzle is a must-visit destination for anyone in Fort Myers seeking an extraordinary dining experience.

Customer reviews

Showing 101–150 of 396 published reviews.

Google

Great vibrant place with fantastic food!

Google

Absolutely loved this place! Cooking your own meat to go with perfectly prepared sides was so much fun, and absolutely delicious. The drinks were incredible (we recommend an espresso martini) and the desserts were all delectable (we tried a few of the cheesecake options). We highly recommend for your next night out!

Google

It was lunchtime and they were super busy and seemed short staffed. The food however was superb with great portion sizes and seasoned well. I had the lobster eggs Benedict with gratin potatoes, just yummy.

Google

This was our first time and we will definitely be going back! We did the for two and ordered the 6 proteins with 2 sides each and 3 sauces each. Ordered the chorizo and spinach artichoke appetizer. It was more than enough next time we would do 5 proteins.

Google

Shout out to my homie Hunter, bro knows a good drink and during a Valentines rush he still took good care of us

Google

We have been back to Sip and Sizzle each of the past 3 weeks. Every time has been great. The food is delicious and we love being able to eat in the heart of Downtown Fort Myers!! Keep up the good work.

Google

Cody was an excellent waiter and provided quality recommendations on drinks and menu options. The girls had a lot of fun with the Sizzle Stone. I opted for a more reserved approach and had Chilean Sea Bass. The manager stopped by as I wish to swap out asparagus for brussel sprouts and that was not a problem. I would definitely give this restaurant another visit.

TripAdvisor

I loved everything! The artichoke dip, Cooking the fillet and Portobello on the 500° stone, and the sauces that came with it. My apple cider cocktail was awesome. Our server was very attentive. The restaurant is in a lively location in downtown Fort Myers.

Google

A hidden gem. Exceptional food, amazing, cocktails, and an outstanding service staff. If you get Lexi that just makes the night even better. Overall, a great vibe.

TripAdvisor

Reviews are accurate—food and cocktails are very good. Our steak and lobster entrees were wonderfully proportioned and of good quality. We opted to grill our food independently, and it was easy and done to perfection. Dirty martinis were mixed perfectly. We will return.

Google

I loved this place!!! The food was delicious especially the salmon cakes! We got the sizzle plate and the portions were perfectly sized so we could finish everything and not feel overly full. We also got the key lime bar at it was the best I’d ever had! It was super creamy the crust was perfect and it was just the right amount of tart vs sweet that makes you want more! The only thing I didn’t like was the lemoncello. It may be because it was something im inexperienced with but it wasn’t my cup of tea. But overall a great experience will 100% go again

Facebook

We went there with 11 people, including four kids. They accommodated us outside it was truly amazing. The food we chose to cook ourselves and it is different but it delicious.

Google

Service was amazing and a wonderful experience. Will definitely be visiting again

Google

Nice atmosphere, good service and great food. Interesting to finish off cooking your dinner at your table on a 500 degree hot grill.

Google

We loved the entire experience.

TripAdvisor

I took a friend one-day and came back the next day with more friends to celebrate Christmas eve. The food was delicious. The service excellent. And the concept unique and fun!

OpenTable

Good food, good drinks, good service, good vibes all for a good price!

Google

Keeley was a fantastic server and the food was fantastic! Manager came by a couple times to be sure all was good and gave us free dessert for my birthday and our anniversary.... definitely going back!!

Google

We had a great time at dinner! It was fun to cook our own steaks on our individual grills. 2 of us got the Angus fillet (upcharge) and one of us got the regular filet and they were both delicious. The steak was so good that we didn’t even need the sauces to dip it in. We also got the gluten free flourless dessert and it was to die for ! We can’t wait to go back !!! Sorry, I didn’t get a better picture before I’d eaten half my steak.

Google

Emily is one of the most talented players on the team ! She is the best! Food , staff and atmosphere are outstanding.. thank you always making us feel so special!

Google

An enjoyable dining experience!

Google

TripAdvisor

Great craft cocktails and fun dining experience. The staff was very friendly and provided great service. We will definitely return.

Google

It was a very nice experience. Our waiter was helpful and humorous. Drinks weren’t watered down and had a good amount of alcohol. The meat that was cooked on the stone was cooked perfectly and we didn’t have to do too much cooking either. The sides and sauces were great too. 10/10 for sure

Google

We had a lovely dinner at Sip & Sizzle for my birthday, and it was absolutely wonderful! The food was amazing—the sizzle stones were so much fun and incredibly delicious. The cocktails were yummy too. Pistachio lovers, you have to try the Pistachio Martini—its a standout! A huge thank you to our server Lexi, who gave us fantastic recommendations and took the time to explain the sizzle stone and how they work. She truly made the experience even better. Highly recommend Sip & Sizzle for a romantic dinner, celebrating a special occasion, or just a fun night out on the town. Well definitely be back!

Google

The burger was the best I have ever eaten in my life!!! My husband got the sizzle stone and the meat was delicious. All the sides and apps were fantastic. What a great restaurant.

Google

We had a great experience our first time trying Sip & Sizzle. We sat at the bar and the food and service was excellent.

Google

Food was excellent! Racquel made us feel like we were important! Great experience!

Google

Hunter gave us great service and the food and experience are amazing

OpenTable

We had a wonderful meal here yesterday . Our server Raquel was so nice & helpful in explaining how the menu works. We ordered their special plate where you choose proteins, sides & sauces. Raquel had great thoughts & ideas for what we were choosing to go with our proteins & they matched up perfectly! We would definitely return if we lived here!

OpenTable

Love the hot stone sizzling at your table! Great choices great Caesar/kale salad. Lots of drink choices. Our server Raquel was so friendly and attentive!

Google

Food and atmosphere was fabulous but the evening really was made amazing by our waiter Noah.

OpenTable

The drinks, food, and service was outstanding! We had dinner at the bar and Elliot, the bartender, was great and a lot of fun! Will definitely go back when back in town.

Google

Everything was fantastic and Noah is a great server with good knowledge of the drinks and food..

Google

Great food and service! The waiter was really attentive to our table and gave us great recommendations for food and drinks. Everything was delicious! Would definitely recommend!

Google

Hunter is the best!!!!

Google

Food and drinks were amazing! I wish the meats for the blackstone were seasoned but I also understand that’s where your sauces come in to play too. Other than that it was a great experience!

Google

Great place to go for a date night. Lovey dining experience. The food was delicious, the service was great & the atmosphere was inviting.

OpenTable

We’re were seated for our reservation within 10 mins. Dante was very friendly, quick and professional. He also made awesome filthy martinis! Hunter was our waiter. He was very helpful with our order on our protein selection and sauces to match. Hunter was knowledgeable, very professional and fun. Really made for an enjoyable evening with friends.

Google

Excellent food and a unique fun experience

Google

This is a really cool concept. You are given lots of choices for proteins, sides and sauces. You receive a hot grill and cook your food to your liking. Delicious and quality food service was excellent! Matt assisted us with the concept and selection. Highly recommend!

Google

Food was great and Lexi our server was excellent ,very pleasant And helpful.

OpenTable

Once again, I had a memorable experience at Sip and Sizzle! It is such a fun and unique eatery! We had a table of 5 women and we had lots to talk about! Our server, Emily B. was amazing. She was so accommodating, cheerful, helpful (great recommendations!), and never once rushed us along. It was a delightful evening and the food was delicious! No doubt, I will be coming back and telling friends about this great restaurant. 😊

Frequently asked questions

What is the dining experience like at Sip & Sizzle?

Sip & Sizzle offers a unique dining experience where guests can cook their own proteins on hot stones at the table, complemented by a variety of sides and sauces. The atmosphere is described as trendy and comfortable with attentive service.

Do I need a reservation to dine at Sip & Sizzle?

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for larger parties, and can be made online in advance to ensure seating preferences such as indoor or outdoor dining.

Are there vegetarian or non-beef protein options available?

The menu includes vegetarian options, but protein choices outside of beef are limited, with some guests noting a desire for more chicken options. The menu is creative and offers a variety of appetizers and sides.